Maggie Mae’s | New Paltz, NY
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Private Events
  • Press
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Private Events
  • Press
  • Contact Us
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

ALL DAY MENU

Soup

French Onion Soup     $9
caramelized onions, beef and chicken broth, fresh herbs, broiled provolone      

Salads

Caesar (v)    ​small $10  large $14
​croutons, creamy caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and crisp romaine.    
​

House Salad (v)    
$9
mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, and onions. Choose ranch, blue cheese, balsamic, lemon vinaigrette.  

Greek Salad (vg)    $14
mixed greens with lemon vinaigrette, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta, olives, and banana peppers     
​
Picture of greek salad being eaten by a person with a fork
Picture of a plate full of jumbo wings and a persons arm in the background with a glass of water

​Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks     $13
battered and fried golden brown, served with tomato basil sauce     

Big Pretzel      $14
jumbo bavarian pretzel with dijon mustard and Maggie's cheese sauce     

Jumbo Wings (10)         $16
served with ranch or blue cheese. Choose garlic parm, BBQ, or buffalo style

Quesadilla       chicken $15  veggie $13
tortilla loaded with peppers, onions, and cheddar jack cheese blend, served with sour cream and pico de gallo  
 

Dublin Nachos         $16
house fried potato chips with pico de gallo, sour cream, melted cheddar jack, and Maggie's Cheese sauce, with your choice of chicken or veggies

Spinach Dip Gratin (vg)      $12 +extra pita $3
spinach and artichokes in a garlic cream sauce topped with broiled provolone, served with warm pita

Handhelds

Served with house-made chips or fries. Side salad +$3

Burgers

all burgers are 8oz. Certified Angus Beef served on a fresh brioche bun with a pickle. Gluten Free Bun $2
Picture of pulled pork sandwich on a plate with a person with painted nails grabbing a french fry
Hickory Burger     $17
topped with bacon, fried onions, BBQ sauce and cheddar jack cheese

Malaka Burger
     $17
topped with feta cheese, banana peppers, mixed greens, and garlic aioli
​Mac Burger    $18
topped with American mac and cheese and Maggie's cheese sauce
​

Veggie Burger
    $17
roasted golden vegetables, with lettuce, tomatoes and onion
​
photo of a plate with avocado toast in foreground, quesadilla and fries in background
Picture
Avocado Toast (v)    $14
mixed greens and guacamole served on a toasted pita with everything bagel seasoning

Crabcake Sandwich
    $20
lump crab cake with garlic aioli and greens served on a brioche bun

Buffalo Chicken Wrap    $15
crispy Buffalo chicken, lettuce, and tomato with ranch or blue cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich    $15
smoked and braised in cola, topped with BBQ sauce, slaw, and a pickle on brioche

Philly Steak    $17
thinly shaved beef with peppers, onions, and Maggie's cheese sauce on a baguette

Falafel (vg)    $15
fried chickpea and herbs served in a pita with mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, and garlic aioli

Reuben    $17
corned beef with thousand island dressing, sauerkraut, and swiss cheese on rye bread

Entrees

Mac & Cheese (vg)      $18
penne tossed in Maggie's cheese sauce and melted cheddar jack cheese
 
Penne a la Sambuca (vg)      $19
blush tomato sauce, anisette, parmesan cheese
Add grilled chicken $5 crispy chicken $6 or shrimp $7


Penne Primavera (v)     $18
garlic, extra virgin olive oil, seasonal vegetables

Pulled Pork    $23
topped with bbq sauce and served with slaw and mac and cheese

10oz CAB Strip Steak     $34
Certified Angus Beef served with mashed potatoes and vegetables
Picture
Picture
French Onion Meatloaf    $22
french onion seasoning, marsala sauce, melted provolone, served with mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables

Fish & Chips    $19
Harp beer battered wild cod served with french fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce and a pickle
 
Chicken Française     $23   
egg battered chicken breast with a lemon white wine sauce served with mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables

Chicken & Waffle    $25
boneless breasts served with a pearl sugar waffle topped with smoked maple syrup, cinnamon cream cheese, and pickle

Kid's Menu

sub fries for salad +$3
Pasta    $12
with marinara sauce or butter

Chicken Tenders    $12
crispy chicken tenders served with fries
Cheeseburger    $15
8oz burger topped with American cheese, served with fries

Grilled Cheese  $12
served with fries
One mile from Main Street, New Paltz
215 Huguenot Street • New Paltz, NY 12561
Book your Maggie Mae's reservation on Resy
CALL NOW
© 2025 Maggie Mae’s. All Rights Reserved.